The Unfinished School of Democracy

Print or Email This Article

Tanzania has millions of registered voters, yet far fewer true citizens. The ballot alone does not transform a mwananchi into a raia. It gives the right to choose, but not the capacity to hold accountable. In every election cycle, voter numbers are celebrated as a triumph of democracy. But democracy is not only about how many people stand in line to cast ballots; it is about whether those votes translate into active citizenship.

As one line captures the dilemma: “Having the vote does not make you a raia. It only makes you a mwananchi with a ballot.” A democracy full of passive voters remains shallow, easily manipulated by handouts, slogans, and patronage. The actual work of democracy begins the day after elections, and it depends on civic education.

The Illusion of Numbers: Voters ≠ Citizens

Every five years, Tanzania registers impressive voter numbers. Politicians proudly announce turnout figures, often above regional averages. On the surface, it appears to be a healthy democracy. But beneath the numbers lies a dangerous illusion: voters are not the same as citizens.

A mwananchi can cast a ballot without ever understanding the meaning of rights, duties, or accountability. They may vote for a candidate because of tribal loyalty, religious affiliation, or the promise of a kilo of sugar offered during campaigns. Once the vote is cast, their role comes to an end. By contrast, a raia does not stop at the ballot box. They ask, ‘Where is the budget?’ Where are the services? Where is the transparency?

As one phrase puts it starkly: “Wananchi hupiga kura; raia hufuatilia bajeti.” Subjects cast ballots; citizens follow the budget. The former is symbolic participation; the latter is substantive democracy.

This gap explains why high voter numbers coexist with weak accountability. Tanzania may have millions of voters, but far fewer citizens who can sustain democratic institutions. Without civic education, the illusion persists: we mistake ballots for democracy when in reality they are only the beginning.

The Roots of Uraia – Education Beyond Literacy

Faithful citizenship is taught, cultivated, and reinforced through practice. It does not emerge automatically with age, nor do voter registration cards confer it. Julius Nyerere understood this when he argued that education was not just about producing workers but about shaping responsible citizens.

Formal literacy is necessary but not sufficient. Schools that teach reading and writing but fail to teach rights and obligations produce wananchi who can read campaign posters but cannot question policies. Universities that train engineers and accountants but neglect civic consciousness create professionals who excel in their fields yet remain politically passive.

Citizenship requires deliberate civic education, exposure to the Constitution, an understanding of taxation, the role of Parliament, and the power of collective action. It also requires lived experience. Participation in community groups, student organizations, local councils, and public forums trains individuals to act as raia.

As one line reminds us: “Uraia haupewi, unajengwa.” Citizenship is not given; it is built. And as another expands: “Raia wanajengwa kwa elimu, taarifa, na uzoefu wa kushiriki.” Citizens are built through education, information, and the practice of participation.

Without these roots, Tanzania risks producing educated professionals who remain politically passive, citizens on paper, subjects in practice.

The Transactional Trap: Elections as Markets

When civic education is absent, elections degenerate into markets. Voters become customers; politicians become traders. Sugar, rice, kitenge, or a small bribe becomes the currency of politics. Instead of platforms and policies, handouts secure loyalty.

This is the transactional trap. It thrives where people do not understand their rights and obligations. A mwananchi sells their vote cheaply because they do not see its long-term value. A raia, by contrast, knows that a kilo of sugar cannot buy five years of accountability.

As one observation cuts sharply: “Wananchi wanauzwa kwa kilo ya sukari; raia hawawezi kununuliwa.” Subjects are sold for a kilo of sugar; citizens cannot be bought.

The consequences are corrosive. Politicians invest more in handouts than in policy. Campaigns become spectacles of giveaways rather than debates of ideas. The electorate remains dependent, not empowered. Democracy becomes shallow, a contest of wallets rather than visions.

This is why civic education matters. It disrupts the market logic of the election process. It teaches people that votes are not commodities but instruments of accountability. It transforms transactional politics into participatory politics. And it reminds leaders that they cannot buy citizens, only convince them.

Global Lessons: How Civic Education Builds Democracy

The story of citizenship is also the story of civic education worldwide. Nations that have deepened democracy have always paired political participation with deliberate civic training.

In Europe, trade unions, workers’ movements, and socialist parties acted as “schools of citizenship.” Workers not only negotiated wages; they also learned to organize, vote, and hold governments accountable. This grassroots civic education created a culture of accountability that parliaments could not ignore.

In the United States, the civil rights movement was not just a struggle for rights but also a vast exercise in civic education. Churches, community centers, and universities became classrooms where African Americans learned not only to demand equality but also to practice democracy through marches, sit-ins, and voter registration drives. This education forged a generation of citizens who would not settle for symbolic inclusion.

Closer to home, Kenya and Uganda provide instructive lessons. Civic education campaigns around constitutional reform, often led by NGOs, helped ordinary people understand complex legal documents and their rights within them. The result was not perfect, but it expanded public ownership of national charters.

The pattern is unmistakable: “Raia hufundishwa kudai; wananchi hufundishwa kutii.” Citizens are taught to demand; subjects are taught to obey. Where civic education is absent, obedience tends to thrive. Where it is present, demands rise.

Tanzania’s Civic Gap – Why We Lag Behind

In Tanzania, civic education remains sporadic, shallow, and donor-driven. It is often treated as an election-season project: a few workshops, brochures, and radio jingles urging people to register and vote. Once ballots are cast, the campaigns vanish.

This episodic approach misses the essence of civic education. Citizenship is not an event; it is a habit. It must be woven into daily life, taught from childhood, and reinforced through institutions. Currently, schools teach civics as a subject, but too often it is memorized for exams rather than lived as a practical experience. Students may recite constitutional articles, but they rarely experience active debate or decision-making.

As one critical reflection notes: “Wananchi wanasubiri mafunzo ya kura; raia wanahitaji mafunzo ya kila siku.” Subjects wait for election-time training; citizens need everyday learning.

The digital age could have changed this, but progress is uneven. While Tanzania has invested heavily in ICT infrastructure, digital literacy is still primarily framed in terms of employability, rather than democratic participation. Young people may use smartphones for entertainment but lack the skills to use them for budget tracking, civic organizing, or government monitoring. The result is a gap: the infrastructure of citizenship exists, but the culture of citizenship lags.

Closing the Gap – Teaching Democracy

Bridging this gap requires deliberate effort. Just as Tanzania has invested in roads, power plants, and schools, it must also invest in civic education as a form of infrastructure for democracy.

Four steps stand out:

1. Integrate Civic Education Across the Curriculum: From primary to tertiary levels, civic education must be more than a subject; it must be a pedagogy. Students should debate policies, simulate parliaments, and practice democratic decision-making.
2. Leverage Digital Platforms: Civic education must meet citizens where they are: on phones, social media, and online forums. Budget trackers, fact-checking tools, and e-government platforms must be taught as civic tools, not just technical conveniences.
3. Link Taxes to Rights: Public campaigns should explicitly connect taxation to accountability. When citizens see how their money is spent on services, they will demand results.
4. Make Civic Education Continuous: Elections should not be the only moments of civic training. Local councils, community radios, and workplaces can be ongoing classrooms of democracy.

In short, democracy must be taught deliberately, not assumed passively.

The Unfinished School

Tanzania has built schools, expanded literacy, and connected citizens to the digital world. But it has not yet built the most crucial classroom: the school of citizenship.

As one reminder puts it: “Kura ni mwanzo wa uraia, siyo mwisho wake.” The vote is the beginning of citizenship, not its end.

For Tanzania to transition from wananchi to raia, civic education must stop being an afterthought and become a national project. Only then will voters become citizens, ballots become a measure of accountability, and democracy become more than a market of handouts.

The unfinished school of democracy awaits its students.